NTKOG #179: The kind of self confident customer who, maligned by her own shoddy purchasing decisions, flies in the face of capitalism by demanding a for-free do-over.
I am: to blame for everything bad that befalls me.
I am not: a fan of the phrase “the customer is always right.” I dunno, guys. How ’bout: “the person who makes $7/hr at a soul-sucking job should be treated really, really nicely, lest they snap”?
The Scene: Not my own guilty conscience, for once. Fun fact? I don’t know that I’ve ever returned a purchase to a store. Too-baggy shirts, expired pizza dough, rancid candles — if I buy something displeasing, forget the store’s culpability: this is one emptor that should have caveated a little harder.
That said, stores do have return policies for a reason (and jacked-up profit margins for another reason entirely), so, for one week, threw aside my laziness and consumer cringing and demanded what was mine.
Return the first: Early to work one morning, picked up a pack of added-fiber toaster pastries (god isn’t that a depressing phase of life: young enough to crave Pop Tarts; old enough to legitimately angst over roughage), bit into one and realized, frig, even more cardboardy than anticipated. Quick glance at the box summed up that mystery: apparently the tarts had expired sometime around my senior year of college.
Dashing back to Walgreens, I almost lost my nerve. A middle-aged man was leaning heavily on the counter, berating the steely-faced salesclerk because the store doesn’t carry flipflops year-round. But when he finally finished, I took my turn — shuddering with mortification — and before I’d even finished explaining, the clerk gestured toward the store and told me to pick out another pack. Flaky, fibrous victory.
Return the second: CVS in Harvard Square, where I picked up a bottle of nail polished touted for its ability to dry to the touch in thirty seconds. Practically skipped home in anticipation, I was so excited. When I went home and got to paintin’, I felt like a giggly schoolgirl painting her nails with White Out in the middle of a boring chemistry lecture. Sadly, my nails also came out looking as though I’d painted ‘em with White Out.
Er, make that Bilious Salmon Out.
Few days later, ran back to CVS with my receipt and — bam, made the exchange in mere minutes. Promptly exchanging it for a bottle of black nail polish. One of the many reasons I’m largely unemployable.
Return the third: Sat alone in a local bar, ingesting a little Waugh with big dreams of a gin and ginger. When the bartender slid up a gin and tonic (blech), the whole “customer is always right” bit was so old hat with me that I didn’t even close my book before smiling sweetly: “Sorry, I asked for a gin and ginger. I’d drink this instead but, uh, I don’t have malaria.”
I got the gin and ginger because I asked for it. But I’d like to think the bartender let me keep the gin and tonic only because of my newfound self-assurance.
The Verdict: Sometimes I forget that we teach people how to treat us, every moment of every interaction. And apparently I am worth more than moldy toaster pastries and unpalatable mixers. So that’s a small check in my column of Things That Are Going Right.
Seriously, I’m not sure why it’s always such an ordeal for me to stand up for myself in front of strangers. I wouldn’t let any of my friends settle for the teensiest breath of sub-par treatment, so why am I often afraid to demand better for myself? Do y’all ever get self-assertion anxiety?
{ 25 comments… read them below or add one }
“Sometimes I forget that we teach people how to treat us, every moment of every interaction.”
This is something I’m trying to work on every day. And I love that idea; we teach people how to treat us. It’s tough for me to demand better for myself, and always has been. I have a terribly hard time riding what I see as the fine line of being assertive and being demanding, and so instead of riding that line I opt for the more socially acceptable thing, which is a tendency towards being seriously “flexible.” The older I get the more I realize being “flexible” has no real benefit to anyone, especially me. Definitely one of the harder habits for me to break.
Great post, and great lesson. Definitely something more people could benefit from.
All my best to you always,
Carolina
That was the line that most jumped out at me (together with the one I mentioned below), too. Also, I have also been realising recently that “being “flexible” has no real benefit to anyone, especially me.” It’s an interesting concept, and something definitely worth working on!
Great social post. Have we been trained that it’s just not worth the hassle?
How does price affect the decision to return?
How does the frequency that we shop at the store and familiarity with the staff affect the decision?
The easy answer I know is that it shouldn’t, but yet???
I definitely return anything that has something wrong with it (that’s not my fault), but my partner is the type to not return anything under €10, or at stores he frequents… or if he’s just feeling lazy that day! I think all of things you mentioned are factors for some people, while others won’t let things like “it only cost $2 to begin with” stop us from attaining the correct product. For me, it’s not about the price, or the inconvenience posed to the employees of the store, it’s about enjoying that bottle of nail polish (or whatever)–there was usually a reason I bought it in the first place.
Sorry, I had a male moment there. When I swapped “new tool” for “nail polish”, evrything changed. It’s getting returned. Probably not today, but it’s getting returned!
I really hate to type this out loud but if I were to be honest, my middle name should be “Doormat.”
I think the origin of this programming started with being raised by my loving but extremely accomodating first generation Asian mom.
“Bilious Salmon Out” = um, ew! Yet so perfectly described that I like it (I’m a huge fan of precise description, even if used to describe the least favorable color ever*).
*This includes anything in the peach/coral family. I blame my mother for painting my childhood bedroom 80s peach with a flowered border… and I actually really love my childhood home (and happy childhood), just not that horrid color. *shudder*
Aww, good for you. Although I do favor the gin and tonic because of the malaria prevention qualities. You never know with malaria. (Or volcanoes.)
I couldn’t agree more, particularly with your final comment about your willingness to assert for others but not for yourself. It’s astonishing to me that the confidence we instill for others rarely translates to confidence in ourselves. I don’t like to think of myself as a doormat, but if the shoe fits (and stomps all over you), then…
I hadn’t thought of it that way, but it’s so true. Rather than playing victim to the actions of others, you can be in that much control.. of course, without being bitchy about it.
I’ve been returning things more now than in the past. Except of course, when it’s a sale that says no returns/exchanges.
I’m glad I’m not alone on this one. I thought I didn’t take things back because I was lazy, and I’m sure that’s part of it.. but more than that I hate telling someone I don’t like what they gave me… even if I paid for it! I need some balls.
Yes! I’m a total wimp. I’m trying to work on it though. You know, usually the worst thing they can do is say ‘no’, but I’ve worked enough shitty customer service low pay jobs to know what assholes most people are and I just don’t want to add to the stress of another person’s day.
YES. omg!! I do. Just Saturday I was at Applebee’s. My friend had paid for a friend of his at another table- cause he’s just awesome like that- and the other table’s waiter hadn’t brought his card back- by the time our checks came, so I got loud and mentioned he would need it BACK to pay for his own meal, and got it promptly. But my own waiter brought me a Apple Sangria- when I had ordered an Apple MARGARITA, and I said “No, its fine I’ll drink it anyway,” in the most PLEASANT of tones. O_o WTF, right?? haha
I think everyone should “do time” working retail. It changes your perspective a lot when it comes to interactions in a store. I handled returns all the time when I put in my years at American Eagle and it’s nothing personal when you have to bring something back. It might be different in food service though considering those folks gets chewed out far worse and make far less. I less-than-rarely complain at restaurants, send food back, demand compensation drinks, etc out of some self-inflicted guilt complex when it comes to food service :(
“I wouldn’t let any of my friends settle for the teensiest breath of sub-par treatment”
me neither, I always think “they’re right, I’m wrong”, I don’t know why… but since I realized that I treat my friends better than I do with myself things started to change… for better! ;)
I have returned things for other people, so I realize its not that big a deal. But I won’t do it for myself, unless the item was price-y. I don’t send back food when they get my order wrong, I don’t return faulty clothes or nail polishes. I just…don’t.
I never really thought about it in terms of valuing myself, but I think that’s an interesting point deserving of further personal reflection.
Dammit, reading your blog is going to result in “personal growth.” I kind of hate personal growth.
By the by, I think you have also convinced me to give Wodehouse and Waugh a try. Recommendations on the best ones to start with?
Yay! I’m always so happy to send readers scuttling to the W’s!
Wodehouse: can’t go wrong with the Jeeves stories. The first book is “Carry On, Jeeves,” a collection of ten stories, all of which are absolutely intoxicating. I’m also a huge fan of his stand-alone novels, of which, “Quick Service” and “Laughing Gas” are my favorites so far. (A word of caution, though: his stories are definitely drawing-room farcical, so read them lightly! They definitely don’t pass feminist inspection…)
Waugh: You just can’t go wrong with “Handful of Dust” or “Vile Bodies.” Laugh-out-loud social satire with a serious, serious scathing streak. His novels got heavier (though less mean) when he got super-Catholic later in life, but I personally don’t go in for that old-boy stuff quite as much.
Dude, the thought of someone experiencing Wodehouse for the first time fills me with immense delight! I hope you enjoy it! Let me know what you end up reading and whether you like it!
I hate personal growth too! Unfortunately, the blog is forcing me to do a lot of it, so I’ve had to learn to like it. ;-)
Story of how I stood up for myself and still got nothing:
A little while ago I was at Target and they had little signs on the shelves saying if you buy 2 of the product you get a $5 gift card. I didn’t need 2 of said items, but I did anyway because of that.
When I get to the register it doesn’t show up so I ask politely if she could double-check. Another employee comes over, looks at the ad from the paper and says no, it only applies to certain types/sizes. Though the ad says one thing, it was on a sign directly in front of the product, so I ask her to check the shelves, because if it is mislabeled they would want to fix that anyway.
She does so reluctantly, comes back, and has this confused look on her face. She looks at my items for a few minutes and tries to remember if what she just looked at is what I have (uh, shouldn’t you have brought my items with you to make sure of what you are checking for?) She just decides to say no again.
I was so annoyed, I said, “Are you sure? You don’t sound very certain.” I almost wanted to ask her to go back with me so I could point it out, but it wasn’t worth it anymore. I work in customer service, and that’s not how you resolve issues. So frustrating!
I never hesitate to return items. I am always super respectful of the fact that it isn’t the fault of the person I am working with that the item is defective or unsatisfactory. I have rarely had any problems. The couple of times I did, I just requested to speak to a manager and resolved the situation in an amicable ;) manner.
When you consider that most people who operate in a service providing sector genuinely want to make you happy, returns are supposed to be easy. When returns are more difficult, that is the reddest of red flags… one I never quite understood actually. If you make it difficult for someone to return something, sure, you have guaranteed that the earned profit will stay earned profit, but you have also made it certain that the person will never shop there again.
Restaurant Refugee is right; If you’re returning something defective, past sell-buy when you bought it, wrong/miscooked order or whatever, you are just asserting your legal right. That said, there’s no reason for you to be an @$$-hole about it.
One time, I got a bag of “Crisprolls” (like restaurant rolls, but toasted crisp) home, opened it and discovered they’d been reduced to crumbs in the shop (major supermarket chain).
[cut to customer service des]]
Me – “I bought these yesterday, and when I got home and opened them I discovered they weren’t so much Crisprolls as Crispcrumbs!” (NB, no such thing as Krispee Creme do-nuts over here back then).
Customer Service – [looks in bag] :) “Yes sir, I take it you’d like another bag.”
Me – “Yes please.”
[cut back to now]
So I’d say that if you’re polite and if possible funny about a genuine complaint there’s no need to be embarrassed.
“Seriously, I’m not sure why it’s always such an ordeal for me to stand up for myself in front of strangers. I wouldn’t let any of my friends settle for the teensiest breath of sub-par treatment, so why am I often afraid to demand better for myself? Do y’all ever get self-assertion anxiety?”
NTKOG, that is me to a tee. I think it’s a Virgo thing – are you one? I would rather suffer than ask for help….non-confrontational to the nth…..oh well.
“How ’bout: “the person who makes $7/hr at a soul-sucking job should be treated really, really nicely, lest they snap”?
I cracked up reading that. I currently work in customer service and wish more customers were as understanding as you are.